Meet Esch Insurance

A white background with a few lines on it

Your Local Insurance Specialists

Decades of Dedicated Service

Founded in 1959 by Joseph W. Esch, our agency began by offering health insurance and expanded into property and casualty in 1965. Joseph’s legacy includes significant community involvement and leadership roles in various insurance boards.


Larry Myers and Terry Fischer joined the team in 1977 and 1994, respectively, each bringing specialized expertise and expanding our services. Sandy Fischer stepped in as partner and marketing director in 2007, furthering our growth.


Today, Terry and Sandy lead our agency, continuing our commitment to deliver comprehensive insurance solutions. Through innovation and community dedication, we've built a foundation of trust and expertise.

Explore Our Services

65+

Years in
Business

100+

Years of Combined Insurance Experience

10+

Carrier

Relationships

A man in a purple shirt sits with his arms crossed

Terry Fischer


Terry is President and co-owner of Esch Insurance Agency, Inc. Terry has been with Esch Insurance Agency since 1994 and prior to that he investigated insurance fraud. He holds the designation of CPIA – Certified Professional Insurance Agent.  Terry specializes in the areas of personal, business, life, and health insurance. Terry is an active volunteer in the Dodgeville and Mount Horeb communities.  He is a past board member for the Mount Horeb Area Chamber of Commerce, the Dodgeville Area Chamber of Commerce, and Dodgeville Optimists. 


A woman in a pink shirt and black jacket is standing in front of a green wall.

Sandy (Esch) Fischer


Sandy is co-owner of Esch Insurance Agency, Inc. She joined Esch Insurance in February 2007. She comes to the agency with over 20 years of experience in the area of marketing and is very familiar with Esch Insurance as it has been in her family since 1959. Sandy is a Board of Trustees Member for Upland Hills Health and serves on several committees for the hospital.  She is also a Board Member with Project Home.  She is a past member and officer of the Mount Horeb Optimist Club and occasionally participates as a judge for DECA's regional competitions.


A woman wearing a red sweater and a necklace is smiling for the camera.

Mary Pluemer


Mary has been with Esch Insurance Agency, Inc. since 1999. Mary handles client billing inquiries and the accounting functions for the agency in which she has over 25 years experience. Mary is an active member of her local church and the Dodgeville community. Outside of work, she enjoys hiking, kayaking, and spending time with family.


A woman in a black jacket is sitting in a chair

Erika Forseth


Erika is an agent with Esch Insurance Agency, Inc. She joined Esch Insurance in January 2011. Licensed in property & casualty and life & health, Erika is a seasoned professional with over 20 years in the insurance industry. She also holds her CISR designation (Certified Insurance Service Representative).


A woman in a blue shirt is sitting at a table with her arms crossed.

Kara Brandemuehl


Kara is an agent with Esch Insurance Agency. She is licensed in Property & Casualty Insurance. She has been an agent since 2010 and joined the Esch team in February of 2012. Kara is an active member of the Mount Horeb community. Kara currently serves as the Chair for the Mount Horeb Area Chamber of Commerce Board of Directors. Outside of work, she stays busy volunteering and supporting our local sports teams.

Why Choose Esch Insurance?

A red brush stroke on a white background.
A black and white drawing of two arrows pointing in opposite directions.
Comprehensive Insurance Evaluation

At Esch Insurance, we take the time to evaluate your complete insurance needs, ensuring every aspect of your life and assets is covered. Our thorough assessment guarantees that you receive the most relevant and effective protection for your unique situation.

A black and white icon of a group of people standing next to each other.
Customized Protection Programs

We believe in tailoring insurance solutions to fit your individual needs. By customizing an effective protection program specifically for you, we provide the peace of mind that comes with knowing you have the right coverage in place.

A light bulb with a check mark inside of it.
Competitive and Varied Options

With Esch Insurance, you have access to a variety of insurance options to compare. We present competitively priced proposals, ensuring you can choose the best coverage without breaking the bank.

A black and white drawing of a heart on a white background.
Ongoing Coverage Reviews

Your insurance needs can change over time, and we’re committed to keeping your coverage up to date. We perform periodic reviews of your policies for adequacy and cost-effectiveness, constantly researching ways to save you money while ensuring you receive prompt and fair claim settlements.

Start Your Secure Tomorrow Today.

Ready to enhance your peace of mind? Contact us to discover how our tailored insurance solutions can protect what matters most to you. Let's build a secure future together—reach out now!

Reach Out

Our Specialties 

A red brush stroke on a white background.
Two women and a baby are playing with a hose in the backyard.

Personal Insurance

Personal insurance provides coverage for individuals and families, protecting against financial losses from events like accidents, illness, or property damage.

A sign on a table in front of a window with a view of a field.

Business Insurance

Business insurance protects companies from financial losses due to events that can affect their operation, such as property damage, legal liabilities, and employee-related risks.

Farm Insurance

Farm insurance offers specialized coverage that addresses the unique needs of farmers and agricultural producers, ensuring that operations can recover quickly and continue production.

A herd of black and white cows grazing in a grassy field.
Share by: